Skip to main content
Food & Diet

Is tackling meat consumption too politically toxic?

05 January 2023

Government ministers have been criticised for their handling of emissions relating to meat consumption, after a key Government policy document appeared to circumnavigate the issue. The land use strategy for England – did not include reduction in area used for animal agriculture, despite being designed to ensure the country reaches its net zero and biodiversity targets, while helping farmers adapt to climate change and continue producing high-quality, affordable food. A senior Defra source commented “it’s not up to us to tell people what to eat”.

This is at odds with the government-commissioned National Food Strategy (NFS) which recommended that to achieve a sustainable future, the UK must reduce the proportion of farming land committed to animal agriculture (which stood at 85% at the time).

Henry Dimbleby, who led the NFS review, remarked that no government would tell the public to eat less meat as the message was “politically toxic”. 

In November 2023, food systems campaign group ‘Feedback’ applied to take the Government to Court for a judicial review over its ‘failure’ to tackle food and farming emissions in the Food Strategy. Feedback’s application was rejected, a move which the environmental group said revealed fatal flaws in the Climate Change Act.

Reference article:

  • Source: The Guardian
  • Author: Helena Horton
  • Date: 5th January 2023

The latest from the Food & Diet timeline:

Policy Insight 28th February 2025

Diets shifts in the years ahead: What level of change will be needed and accepted?

According to Climate Change Committee’s (CCC) latest carbon budget, a range of low-carbon choices will form part of a “balanced pathway” towards net zero – with food and diet changes making “smaller, but important contributions” to this transition.  Household low-carbon choices contribute to one-third of emissions reduction in 2040, while a shift in average meat and dairy consumption are anticipated to make up 6% of these household emissions reductions. The CCC note that:

“By 2040, 25% of meat (30% of red meat) and 20% of dairy is replaced with lower-carbon foods, compared to 2019 consumption levels”

Drawing on evidence from a Citizens’ Panel, which was convened as part of the report, the CCC found that:   

  • The public generally accepted the need for changes in diet. However, what was considered possible and acceptable varied a lot by person.
  • People expressed surprise about the emissions impact of different foods, and there was consensus that government should proactively providing more information to the public to support a shift towards lower-carbon foods.
  • People expressed a clear preference for a shift towards healthier, home-cooked options and saw education around plant-based meal preparation as another way to support this shift.
  • Panelists agreed the price of plant-based alternatives needs to be reduced to make these more attractive options.
  • There were concerns about people who may be less willing or able to shift to lower-carbon foods, including concerns about the affordability of alternatives for low-income families.
  • And there was concern about negative impacts on UK farmers – people wanted to ensure policies existed to ensure farmers are supported.

Interestingly, much of the news coverage of the Carbon Budget focused on diet shifts, despite a greater emphasis on other measures. (Electrification and low-carbon electricity supply make up the largest share of emissions reductions in the CCC’s pathway – 60% by 2040).

  • Source: Climate Change Committee
  • Author: CCC
  • Date: 26th February 2025
View Food & Diet timeline now

Add Feedback